The Geology of D.A.R. State Park, Mt. Philo State Forest Park, Sand Bar State Park

THE GEOLOGY OF
D.A.R. STATE PARK

Shoreline at D.A.R. State Park looking south.

MT. PHILO STATE FOREST PARK

Panoramic view from west overlook on Mt. Philo. Adirondack Mountains in background. Lake Champlain and Champlain Lowlands in foreground.

SAND BAR STATE PARK

Sand Bar State Park on flat surface of Lamoille River delta. A part of extensive picnic area looking northwest.

THE GEOLOGY OF
D.A.R. STATE PARK
MT. PHILO STATE FOREST PARK
SAND BAR STATE PARK

By
HARRY W. DODGE, JR.

VERMONT GEOLOGICAL SURVEY
CHARLES G. DOLL, State Geologist

DEPARTMENT OF FORESTS AND PARKS
ROBERT B. WILLIAMS, Commissioner

DEPARTMENT OF WATER RESOURCES
Montpelier, Vermont

1969

3

Fig. 1. Index Map.

SANDBAR STATE PARK
MT. PHILO STATE PARK
BUTTON BAY STATE PARK
D.A.R. STATE PARK
LAKE CHAMPLAIN
Milton
Burlington
Shelburne Falls
Hinesburg
Vergennes
Bristol
Port Henry
Champlain Bridge
Middlebury
Crown Point
Shoreham
INDEX MAP
4

Fig. 1a. Surface of marine terrace at D.A.R. State Park. Immediately to the left of shelter the land rises to a second terrace.

5

Fig. 2. View northwest along park beach. Illustrates dip of rocks toward northwest; strike, northeast.

THE GEOLOGY OF D.A.R. STATE PARK

INTRODUCTION

D.A.R. State Park is located in western Vermont on State Highway 17, approximately 1 mile north of Lake Champlain (toll) Bridge (see map, Fig. 1). The park, which fronts on Lake Champlain, contains undeveloped acres on the east side of the Highway. Tenting, leanto camping, picnicking and swimming are adequately provided for during the summer months.

This park, more than most others, not only awakens the visitor’s curiosity about the past history of the Earth, but satisfies it. The story of an ancient sea and the life which existed in it can be read from the rocks exposed in D.A.R. State Park. You can read this story for yourselves. This Pamphlet is designed as an aid to a more complete understanding of the observations which you make. “Reading the rock record” is not difficult, but the geologist does have the advantage of possessing a certain trained scientific approach to these problems. This method of approach, the “tools of the trade,” will now be passed on to you.

6

THE GEOLOGY OF THE PARK

The park beach is the ideal place to study the rocks of the park, for here the rocks are best exposed and can be easily examined at close range. The attitude of the rock layers can be seen on a walk down the ramp. By attitude is meant their relationship to an imaginary horizontal plane, which for our purposes is the level of the lake. Are the rock layers parallel to the surface of Lake Champlain or do they slant or dip into it? If the layers were parallel to the surface they would not “dip.” The dip of the park strata (layers) is seen in Figure 2. Dip is expressed in the number of degrees down from the horizontal and here the dip is toward the west and is measured to be between 8 and 11 degrees. The dip is always measured perpendicular to an imaginary horizontal line on a rock layer called a “strike line.” The average “strike,” or compass direction of the “strike line” is 22 degrees east of north.[1]

Sedimentary rocks[2] crop out on the park beach. These were originally lime mud resting on the sea bottom. Under continued pressure from the overlying sediments resulting from continued deposition and burial, the muds were slowly compacted and cemented into the hard limestones and limy shales which we see today. The many layers of rock were then tilted. Tilted layers tell the geologist of giant earth movements which took place since their formation. The story of these movements will be developed later in this pamphlet.

As you look at the tilted rock layers from the ramp, can you tell which layers are the oldest, that is, those first deposited as lime muds on the sea bottom? A basic geologic law, the Law of Superposition, states that if a series of sedimentary layers have not been overturned, the oldest is on the bottom and the youngest on top. Assuming that the layers which you are looking at have not been overturned, those on your left (south) are the oldest and those on your right (north) the youngest. Looking at Figure 2, taken from the ramp-bottom toward the north, the layers in the foreground are older than those in the distance. Let us take a close look at the individual layers of rock and delve deeper into the story that they have to tell.

7

Fig. 3. Block diagram illustrating dip and strike.

STRIKE DIRECTION
ROCK LAYER
SURFACE (PLANE) LAKE LEVEL
HORIZONTAL
DIP
ROCK LAYER

Search the top of a few layers and you will notice many shell and other animal impressions. Do they represent animals which lived hundreds of millions of years ago or were they washed onto these rocks from present-day Lake Champlain? If you try to make a collection of the shell impressions you will see that they are a part of the rock and therefore must represent remains of animals that were buried in the 8 ancient lime muds. These preserved remains[3] are called fossils. The geologist who specializes in the study of fossils is called a paleontologist. You may ask, “What can fossils tell me about the past?” In the first place, fossils tell us at what time in the past the sediments in which they are found were deposited. In this way, the relative age[4] of the rock layers found in the Park can be learned. Secondly, the environment or surroundings in which these ancient sediments were deposited can be reconstructed from the types of fossils contained within them. Certain animals living today are quite similar to those in the Park rocks and their environment in today’s sea can be used to reconstruct the environment of animals which lived in the past. The characteristics of the rocks and their relation to adjacent rocks are considered in any reconstruction of past environment. In the third place, the study of fossils is a mainstay of the theory of evolution. That is to say, changes in fossil forms collected from groups of successively younger rock layers document the theory that life has evolved little by little since its first appearance on Earth. Finally, it should be mentioned that some animals found as fossils are not living today and have not lived, to the best of our knowledge, for millions of years. Why did these forms of life die out? What set of circumstances led to their extinction? The answers to these questions are not easy to find and they are highly speculative.

9

Fig. 4. Standard Geologic Time Scale.

GEOLOGIC TIME
ERA YEARS AGO PERIODS EVENTS
CENOZOIC 70,000,000 CENOZOIC MAN (1½ MILLION)
MESOZOIC 125,000,000 CRETACEOUS END OF DINOSAURS
165,000,000 JURASSIC FIRST BIRD
200,000,000 TRIASSIC FIRST DINOSAUR
PALEOZOIC 230,000,000 PERMIAN END OF TRILOBITES
260,000,000 PENNSYLVANIAN
290,000,000 MISSISSIPPIAN
330,000,000 DEVONIAN
360,000,000 SILURIAN
420,000,000 ORDOVICIAN ROCKS OF D.A.R. STATE PARK
500,000,000 CAMBRIAN
BEGINNING OF FOSSIL RECORD
1 BILLION
2 BILLION
3 BILLION
4 BILLION
PRECAMBRIAN

THE FOSSILS

Many groups of invertebrates are represented in the fossils of D.A.R. State Park. Plate 1 will help you to identify these fossils. The name, phylum (major group) and age of each fossil are provided in the explanation of the plate. The following paragraphs describe each phylum represented in the Park rocks.

10

Plate 1. Typical fossils found in the Glens Falls Limestone.

Arthropods. D.A.R. State Park rocks contain trilobites with the following imposing names: Cryptolithus tesselatus (crip-toe-LITH-us tessell-AH-tus[5]), Isotelus gigas (ice-so-TELL-us GIG-us) and Flexicalymene senaria (flex-eye-cal-ah-Mean-ee sen-AREA). These fossils are figured on Plate 1, 1-A, B, C, D; 2; 3. Within the Park Cryptolithus tesselatus is very common wherever fossils occur. Generally only the cephalon or head portion of this trilobite is preserved. The cephalon is 11 easily recognized by three concentric rows of pits arranged around the brim. Cryptolithus is an excellent index fossil[6] for the Park rocks. The arthropod phylum is characterized by animals with jointed legs, segmented bodies and a jointed outer armour of chitin.[7] For examples, the crabs, lobsters, spiders, scorpions and insects are arthropods. Trilobites appear early in the fossil record but they did not survive beyond the Paleozoic Era.

Explanation for Plate 1
(all drawings are X1 unless otherwise indicated)

1-A. Cryptolithus tesselatus, Arthropod (Trilobite), Middle Ordovician (Trenton Stage). Front view of the Cephalon or head. (X2)

1-B. Cryptolithus tesselatus, Arthropod (Trilobite), Middle Ordovician (Trenton Stage). Oblique front-lateral view of the Cephalon. (X2)

1-C. Cryptolithus tesselatus, Arthropod (Trilobite), Middle Ordovician (Trenton Stage). Top view of the Cephalon. (X2)

1-D. Cryptolithus tesselatus, Arthropod (Trilobite), Middle Ordovician (Trenton Stage). Side view of the Cephalon. (X2)

2. Isotelus gigas, Arthropod (Trilobite), Middle Ordovician. Top view of specimen.

3. Flexicalymene, Arthropod (Trilobite), Ordovician to Silurian. Top view of an enrolled specimen.

4-A. Dinorthis pectinella, Brachiopod, Middle Ordovician (Trenton Stage). Exterior view of the brachial valve.

4-B. Dinorthis pectinella, Brachiopod, Middle Ordovician (Trenton Stage). Exterior view of the pedicle valve.

5. Reuschella edsoni, Brachiopod, Middle Ordovician. Exterior view of the pedicle valve.

6. Lingula, Brachiopod, Ordovician to Recent.

7-A. Prasopora, Bryozoan, Ordovician. Top view. (X0.5)

7-B. Prasopora, Bryozoan, Ordovician. Side view. (X0.5)

7-C. Prasopora, Bryozoan, Ordovician. Vertical thin section showing the nature and growth of part of a bryozoan colony. (X18)

8. Bryozoan, “twig-like” type, Ordovician to Devonian.

9. Sowerbyella, Brachiopod, Middle and Upper Ordovician. Exterior view of brachial valve. (X2)

10. Rafinesquina, Brachiopod, Middle and Upper Ordovician. Exterior view of the pedicle valve.

11. Platystrophia trentonensis, Brachiopod, Middle Ordovician (Trenton Stage). Anterior or front view.

12. Hesperorthis tricenaria, Brachiopod, Middle Ordovician (Black River and Trenton Stage). Interior view of the pedicle valve.

12

Fig. 5. The surface of a layer or bed of Glens Falls Limestone. Pen points to a colonial Bryozoan Prasopora “head.” These “heads” are very common just south or to your left if walking down the ramp.

Brachiopods. Brachiopods are abundant in the Park rocks (see Plate 1, 4A, B; 5; 6; 9; 10; 11; 12). These invertebrates are small marine animals which generally live in waters no deeper than 600 feet. The two valves of their shell are joined at the back (posterior) end of the body along a hingeline of interlocking teeth and sockets. The shell of the brachiopod is opened or shut by muscles attached to the inside of each valve. Brachiopods are found in the oldest rocks containing definite and abundant fossils. Brachiopods are still living today.

13

Bryozoans. Bryozoans or “moss animals” are very small marine animals which live in colonies. The bryozoans construct their mutual home or colony of lime which is commonly preserved for the fossil record. Large colonies of the fossil Prasopora (prah-sop-OR-ah) are commonly seen on the weathered surfaces of many of the rock layers in the Park (see Plate 1; 7A, B, C; 8 and Figure 5). Individuals of one genus common here, can be recognized by their chocolate drop shapes. Bryozoans first appear in lower Paleozoic rocks and are still living today in clear well-circulated shallow to deep marine water. Considering all of the fossils found in the Park rocks, the past environment is thought to have been a relatively shallow and warm sea.

Fig. 6. This photograph shows the typical thickness of the Glens Falls Limestone beds in the Park area. Note the massive nature of the limestone bed. The 5-inch pen in the center of the picture is for scale.

14

Fig. 7. Sections illustrating the geologic history of D.A.R. State Park.

THE ROCKS AND THEIR HISTORY

Approximately 75 vertical feet of the Glens Falls Limestone occur along the Park beach. The rocks are black[8] or blue-black on a fresh surface, gray or grayish-white on a surface which has been exposed to the weather. Most of the individual beds or layers are 5 to 7 inches thick (see Fig. 6) with the thickest being just under 5 feet. The beds are separated by thin “partings” of rock, many of which contain abundant fossils. The beds consist of massive limestone, shaly limestone or limy shale; the partings are generally limy shale or shaly limestone.

15

Explanation for Figure 7

1. Glens Falls and younger sediments were deposited on the Ordovician sea floor.

2. Sediments hardened into Glens Falls Limestone and younger rocks.

3. Rocks were tilted during the late Ordovician Taconic Disturbance and the younger rocks and part of the Glens Falls Limestone were removed by erosion. Erosion continued for some 350 million years.

4. During the Pleistocene Epoch, which started some 1 million years ago, glacial ice overrode the beveled layers of the Glens Falls Limestone. Hard rocks frozen to the underside of the glacial ice produced scratches or striations in the exposed layers of the Glens Falls Limestone.

5. Glacial lakes Vermont form as the glaciers retreat northward. In between the glacial lakes Vermont and present Lake Champlain, marine waters flooded the valley and formed an arm of the Atlantic Ocean. Clay, silt, sand and gravel were deposited on glaciated Glens Falls Limestone (Fig. 1a).

6. Present-day Lake Champlain formed when relatively greater uplift in the north dammed the Champlain valley.

The rock types found in the Park lead to certain conclusions regarding the environment which existed during their formation. Most of the rocks are composed of lime (limestone) or a mixture of lime, fine sand and mud (limy shale or shaly limestone). The mineral pyrite (FeS₂) is present in many of the rocks. Most of the rocks contain abundant amounts of organic matter. The sediments which make up these rocks were carried to the Ordovician sea by streams flowing primarily from the east. As these streams entered the quiet sea waters the larger followed by the smaller particles began to settle to the bottom. Lime was slowly precipitated from the warm sea water and pyrite formed under stagnant bottom conditions. Organic material accumulated on the bottom and intermixed with the sediments. The poor life-sustaining qualities of much of the bottom waters prevented rapid or complete bacterial action on the accumulated debris and the sediments remained “organic black” in color. Slowly, as the weight of overlying sediments increased, the lower layers were compacted and cemented into the hard limestone and shale which we see today.

16

The tilt or dip of the Park rocks resulted from subsequent earth movements. When were these rocks tilted? From the evidence presented in the Park all that can be said is that they were tilted sometime after hardening and before the Pleistocene glaciers overrode the region during quite recent times (at least 10,000 years ago). Thus, there are some 350 million years of rock record missing in the Park. Can we tell what happened during these “missing” years through a study of only the Park rocks? The answer to this question is partially “yes,” but we must look to the work done in adjacent areas for a more complete story.

The mere fact that there are no rocks representing these millions of years tells us that the sea had withdrawn from the area and that the previously deposited rocks were undergoing erosion during most or all of the missing rock gap (the time not represented by rocks). Information from adjacent areas, however, tells us that the Park rocks were tilted during the Taconic Disturbance which occurred during the final stages of the Ordovician Period. East of the Park, Taconic earth movements are more dramatically exhibited. The rocks are tilted even more than in the Park and are broken by faults or cracks in the earth’s crust. Some of these faults, known as thrust faults, positioned giant slabs of rock far from their original locations and placed older on top of younger rocks.

Following these earth movements there occurred a long period of erosion. Many of the rock layers were stripped off and carried piece by piece by rivers to other regions. Hundreds of millions of years passed and then, less than one million years ago the great glacial ice sheets slowly advanced southward over the Park area. Pieces of hard rock frozen to the underside of the ice sheets scratched and scraped the rock surfaces leaving these scratches or striations for us to see today (near the northern end of the Park beach these striations are common on the outcropping rock). The retreating glaciers created a series of lakes in which clay, silt, sand and gravel were deposited. Today these sediments are found resting on the beveled edges of the Park rocks.

Present-day Lake Champlain owes its existence to a general uplift of the earth’s surface, greater in the north than in the south, perhaps due to the removal of the heavy glacial ice sheet from the area. The greater uplift in the north dammed the Champlain valley which slowly filled with water. For a diagrammatic picture of the geologic history of D.A.R. State Park, see Figure 7.

17

SUGGESTED READING

Beerbower, J. R., 1960, Search for the Past, Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, N.J.

Collinson, C. C., 1959, Guide for beginning fossil hunters, Educational Series 4, Illinois State Geological Survey, Urbana, Ill.

Dunbar, C. O., 1959, Historical geology, John Wiley and Sons, New York.

Fenton, C. L., 1937, Life long ago, The John Day Co., New York.

Goldring, Winifred, 1931, Handbook of paleontology for beginners and amateurs, part 2, Handbook 9, New York State Museum, Albany, New York.

—— ——, 1950, Handbook of paleontology for beginners and amateurs, part 1, Handbook 9, 2nd Edition, New York State Museum, Albany, New York.

Moore, R. C., 1958, Introduction to historical geology, 2nd Edition, McGraw-Hill Book Co., New York.

Shimer, H. W., 1933, Introduction to study of fossils, The Macmillan Co., New York.

Simpson, G. G., 1953, Life of the past, Yale University Press, New Haven, Conn.

Stokes, W. L., 1960, Essentials of earth history, Prentice-Hall, Inc., Englewood Cliffs, N.J.

Welby, C. W., 1961, Bedrock geology of the Central Champlain Valley of Vermont, Vermont Geological Survey Bull. 14.

—— ——, 1962, Paleontology of the Champlain Basin in Vermont, Vermont Geological Survey Special Publication 1.

18

Fig. 7a. View south from Mt. Philo Overlook. Shellhouse and Buck mountains in the distance.

19

Fig. 8. View looking north at western Overlook in the summit area of Mt. Philo. Note Monkton Quartzite layers which are dipping toward the northeast.